Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Don Midwest's avatar

Off topic. The Decline of the West

Emmanuel Todd predicted the collapse of the Soviet Union in his 1979 book. His unusual approach was ignored for the most part. He looked at cultural issues including: infant mortality rising, birthrates declining, and society stagnating.

In 2024 he published a new book: "The Defeat of the West".

Today he posted the text of a new preface to that book. Here are the first two paragraphs:

"Less than two years after the French publication of La Défaite de l’Occident (The Defeat of the West) in January 2024, the book’s main predictions have come true. Russia has weathered the storm militarily and economically. The American military industry is exhausted. European economies and societies are on the verge of implosion. The Ukrainian army has not yet collapsed, but the stage of the West’s disintegration has already been reached.

I have always been hostile to the Russophobic policies of the United States and Europe, but as a Westerner committed to liberal democracy, a Frenchman trained in research in England, the child of a mother who was a refugee in the United States during the Second World War, I am devastated by the consequences for us Westerners of the war waged without intelligence against Russia."

"The dislocation of the West: what threatens us

Emmanuel Todd Oct 06, 2025"

https://emmanueltodd.substack.com/p/the-dislocation-of-the-west-what

Expand full comment
Frank Revelo's avatar

Trump's multidimensional chess consists in flying under the radar of the neo-conservatives and deep state, who have not yet accepted that USA empire is terribly overextended and needs to greatly reduced in size

If Trump came out and openly ordered USA military to leave South Korea and invited China/Russia to henceforth mediate between North and South Korea because that dispute is not USA business, he would be denounced as a traitor. But if Trump simply destroys relations with South Korea, so that South Korea on its own starts to improve relations with China and Russia and eventually North Korea, Trump flies under the deep state radar. Destroying relations with a long-term ally for absolutely no reason doesn't compute, so the deep state can't react to this multidimensional chess maneuver.

Same with implicitly cutting a deal with Russia for Russia to create a sphere of influence in Europe (Ukraine, Baltics, Finland, Slovakia, Hungary, Balkan peninsula), party by military force, partly by trade policies (oil/gas especially). This sphere of influence will weaken Europe and ensures that Europe and the Euro never again pose a competitive threat to USA or US$. This sphere of influence will cost Russia enough to achieve that it will keep Russia inward focused for many decades trying to digest everything, removing Russia as a threat to USA interests in Africa. If Trump openly proposed such a deal with Russia, USA deep state would be horrified and surely remove Trump from power. But the above is what Trump's eccentric behavior is actually accomplishing.

Trump's next masterstrokes (if he lives long enough) might be to destroy the influence of Israel on USA politics, by leading Israel into a disastrous war with Iran, leaving Israel in economic ruins, and destroy the USA financial parasites via a combination of horrible deflationary depression when the AI bubble bursts followed by Argentina style hyperinflation to clean up the debt overhang.

Expand full comment
9 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?