Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Ohio Barbarian's avatar

Your analogy between a possible US attack on Iran and the Athenian Sicilian Expedition is very apt. Such an attack would result in an imperial disaster the likes of which Americans have never experienced.

The Straits of Hormuz WOULD be closed. Fuel prices WOULD shoot up. At least one US aircraft carrier and several other ships WOULD be sunk.

Notice I say "would" and not "will," precisely because the Pentagon knows these things. The reluctance of military professionals to attack Iran is the best hope for peace right now. Ironic, I know, but there it is.

We live in interesting times.

Expand full comment
Pxx's avatar
Mar 29Edited

Re China, I don't think Trump admin has a chance and I think they know it.

Re Iran, I don't think Trump admin has a choice. They got their sponsorship from the Israel lobby to fight Iran, otherwise Biden/Harris were already giving everything else there is to give. And so they do need to contrive some way to keep Moscow from making it too painful - after the US just spent 3 years feeding all kinds of terrorist attacks against Russia.

For some reason still unclear to me, the Trump team (or perhaps the Israeli side) are also in a great hurry to get it all going. One would think they have 2 years before Republicans lose Congressional majorities in the mid-terms. Alistair Crooke presented this theory about legal mechanisms in the defunct JCPOA snapback sanctions provisions which expire next year - (ie to be used as a legal justification for an escalation process that would lead to war, while being able to claim the other side started it), but that's something Blinken/Biden would do. Trump team do these theatrical Austin Powers / Dr. Evil moves like having the Canadians kidnap Meng Wanzhou in order to defeat Huawei. They're not going to care about the timing of a treaty they already scuttled.

I actually think they're simply trying random stuff - with reckless abandon - and seeing what sticks. The one thing they have going for them, is that Russia and China might actually be quite content to have the US commit to an actual war, before doing anything. Which would be very unfortunate, because I think they can prevent it too with a firm show of support.

Expand full comment
8 more comments...

No posts